The meaning of a
sentence is not seen as a sum of the meaning of the words that make up the
sentence. A sentence meaning is a unit of meaning that is carried by the whole sentence.
Based on their meanings, sentences can be classified into seven categories as
follows:
1. Analytic
Sentence.
Analytic sentences are sentences
that are necessarily true. They are true by definition, and are generally
self-explanatory. It tells us about logic and about language use in which the
meaning of the sentence is found to be true according to the facts.In
additional, they often have little to no informative value. Examples of
analytic sentences include:
o
Frozen water is ice.
o
Bachelors are unmarried men.
o
My mother is a female.
2.
Contradictory Sentence.
A
contradictory sentence is any sentences that are necessarily false. It means
that the meaning of the sentence is proved to be false according to the facts.
For examples:
Ø The
river is bigger than the sea.
Ø The
boy is pregnant.
Ø Water
is heavier than iron.
3.
Anomalous Sentence.
An
anomaly is a sentence that is either a contradiction or nonsense. Nonsense is a
sentence that follows grammatical rules but it notates the semantic rules. It
means that nonsense is grammatically true, but semantically wrong.Hurley (1996)
gives a sentence widely used by linguistics to illustrate:
Colorless green ideas sleep
furiously
Explanation:
The
sentence obeys all the syntactic rules of English. The subject is colorless green ideas and the predicate
is sleep furiously. It has the same
syntactic structure as the sentence Dark green leaves rustle furiously.
However, there is obviously something semantically wrong with the sentence. The
meaning of colorless includes the
semantic feature "without color",
but it is combined with the adjective green, which has the semantic feature "green in color". How can
something be both "without color" and "green in color"?
This sentence violates what we know about semantic features and is, therefore,
semantically anomalous.
4.
Synthetic Sentence
In
contrast with analytic sentence, synthetic sentences are descriptions of the
world that cannot be taken for granted. Sentences that are possibly true but
not necessarily true are synthetic. They are based on our sensory data and
experience. The truth-value of a synthetic statement cannot be figured out
based solely on logic (Quine, 1953). It may be true or false depending on the
way the world is.
If
one had no sensory input from the world, then studying the statement would not
yield the meaning of the sentence, as it would for an analytic sentence.
Examples of synthetic sentences are:
o
Mary loves her daughter.
o
The table in the kitchen is round.
o
My computer is on.
5.
Un-interpretable Sentence.
An
interpretable sentence is a sentence that sounds like an English sentence, but
it makes no sense at all because it includes words that have no meaning or words
that do not belong to English and may also happen to other languages. For
instances:
“The
smurf is mlirting the slock seefly in
the klooth”
“My
brother will peetch the clog.”
The
words used in the two sentences above seem like English because the grammar is
actually correct, but the content words in the sentence above are all
senseless.
6.
Paraphrase.
Paraphrases
are sentences having the same meaning or parts of the two sentences are
synonymous. There are two kinds of paraphrases, lexical paraphrase and
grammatical paraphrase.
7.
Ambiguous Sentence.
Ambiguous
sentence has more than one meaning. There are two kinds of ambiguous sentence.
They are:
Ø Lexical
ambiguity: The presence of two or more possible meanings within a single word.
The ambiguous word can be a homonym, a polysemy, or a metaphor. For example,
‘Dr. Jack is a butcher’. Here butcher can mean profession or killer. Other
examples added by Hurley (1996) are:
1.
Sherlock saw the man with the binoculars.
Sherlock
used binoculars to see the man? Or did Sherlock see a man who was wearing
binoculars?
2. Tibetan
history teacher.
A history teacher is
from Tibet,or the teacher of Tibetan history.
3. Shortmen
and women.
Woman
and men who are short, or men and women who are short.
Ø Structural/
Grammatical Ambiguity
The
structure of the grammar of the sentence can be interpreted in more than one
way. For instance
REFERENCES
Hurley,
Pat, K. (1996) . Week 12 Module 4 Lesson
4.3.4 Compositional Semantics.http://emedia.leeward.hawaii.edu/hurley/Ling102web/mod43_semantics/4mod4.3.4_compositional.htm
http://www.rit.edu/cla/philosophy/quine/analytic_synthetic.html
No comments:
Post a Comment